Roof Replacement Cost in Essex County, NJ (2026): Published Prices and What Each Town's Housing Adds

By R&E Roofing14 min read
A large older house on Eagle Rock Way in Montclair, New Jersey, with a round turret, dormers, two brick chimneys and a gray shingle roof beside a tall bare tree
A house on Eagle Rock Way in Montclair, where 59% of homes were built in 1939 or earlier (Census). Illustrative photo, not an R&E Roofing job. Photo: Jim.henderson, Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

The Short Answer

  • $37,335 is the 2025 Cost vs. Value price for tearing off and replacing a 30-square (3,000 sq ft) asphalt roof in its New York, NY market. Middle Atlantic: $37,201. National: $31,871.
  • About $1,245 a square is that figure divided by 30 squares. A square is 100 sq ft of roof. This is arithmetic, not a quote.
  • Metal: $60,246 in the same New York market.
  • Housing age differs a lot by town. In Glen Ridge, Maplewood and Montclair, more than half of homes were built in 1939 or earlier. In Fairfield and Roseland the median home was built in 1974 and 1975.
  • No permit is needed to replace the roof covering on a detached one- or two-family house. Three- and four-family buildings are not named in that rule.
  • No sales tax on a new roof when you sign Form ST-8. A shingle repair is taxable at 6.625%.
  • Winter jobs need hand-sealed shingles, per GAF and Owens Corning instructions.

We found no Essex County or Newark market in the Cost vs. Value report, and no county source that publishes a local roof price. Every figure here is quoted from a source listed at the foot of the page, read on November 18, 2026. R&E Roofing's own prices are in a written estimate for your roof, not on this page.

When we searched for Essex County roof replacement costs on November 18, 2026, none of the nine regular results on Google's first page gave a price for Essex County itself. This page starts from a published survey that prices the same defined roof job in each market it covers. It then sets beside it the Census figures for every Essex County town, because a house in Montclair, where most homes were built in 1939 or earlier, and one in Roseland, where the median home was built in 1975, do not get the same bid.

R&E Roofing's office is at 573 Valley St in Orange, in the middle of Essex County. For what we do across the county, see our Essex County roofing page. For roof materials, insurance and timing across the state, see the New Jersey roof replacement cost guide. The estimate form is at the bottom of this page.

1. What a New Roof Costs in Essex County

The Cost vs. Value report, carried by the Journal of Light Construction, prices one defined job in each market it covers. The asphalt job is spelled out. Remove and dispose of the existing roofing to bare wood sheathing. Install 30 squares of fiberglass asphalt shingles (minimum 235 lb., minimum 25-year warranty). Add new 30-lb. felt or synthetic underlayment, galvanized drip edge and aluminum flashing. The job assumes a rectangular hip roof, two skylights and a vented ridge.

A boom truck lifting bundles of shingles onto the roof of a single-story house while a worker waits on the roof
Shingle bundles lifted onto a roof for a replacement. Illustrative photo, not an R&E Roofing job and not in Essex County. Photo: Alan Levine (cogdogblog), Flickr, CC0.

We found no Essex County or Newark market in the report. The table uses its New York, NY market, its Middle Atlantic region and its national average.

Job cost, 2025 Cost vs. Value report.Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
JobNew York, NY marketMiddle AtlanticNational
Asphalt shingle roof replacement$37,335$37,201$31,871
Metal roof replacement$60,246$60,116$51,865

Sources: Cost vs. Value 2025, New York, NY, Cost vs. Value 2025, Middle Atlantic, the asphalt job description.

Low-slope roofs are a different job, and the Cost vs. Value asphalt figure does not cover them. Section 3 shows where two- to four-unit buildings make up a large share of homes; ask whether yours has a low-slope section. The flat roof replacement cost guide covers those roofs.

2. Price per Square, and Your Roof's Size

Roofers price by the square. Owens Corning and GAF both define a square as 100 square feet of roof. A roofer measures each plane of the roof, adds them up and divides by 100. A pitched roof has more area than the house's footprint, so the square count is usually larger than the floor area suggests.

The New York market figure divided by its 30 squares is about $1,245 a square. The table applies that to other roof sizes. It is arithmetic for orientation, not a quote.

About $1,245 a square, from $37,335 divided by 30 squares.
SquaresRoof areaAt about $1,245 a square
151,500 sq ftabout $18,700
202,000 sq ftabout $24,900
252,500 sq ftabout $31,100
303,000 sq ft$37,335 (the report's own figure)
404,000 sq ftabout $49,800

Sources: Owens Corning, what is a roofing square, GAF, what is a roofing square, Cost vs. Value 2025, New York, NY.

The back of the Clark House in Montclair, New Jersey: a hip roof with several dormers, a pointed corner turret and a brick chimney
The back of the Clark House in Montclair: dormers, hips, a turret and a chimney on one roof. Illustrative photo, not an R&E Roofing job. Photo: Jim.henderson, Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

GAF lists what a contractor weighs beyond the square count. A roof with more rakes, valleys, eaves, overhangs and dormers has more starting and stopping points and more shingle waste. The contractor adds a waste factor and may adjust the price for the roof's complexity and pitch. Ask each bid to show:

  • The measured square count and the waste factor added to it.
  • The roof's pitch, and any steep section priced separately.
  • The number of old layers being torn off.
  • The price for any sheathing that has to be replaced.
  • The chimneys, skylights and walls that get new flashing.

3. Essex County Town by Town

The Census Bureau's American Community Survey shows how old each town's housing is and what kind of buildings it is. The table covers all 22 Essex County municipalities, oldest median year built first. Each town name links to our page for that town.

American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates. Shares are of all housing units, rounded. "1939 or earlier" means more than half of the town's homes are that old, so the Census gives no exact median year.Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
TownMedian year builtBuilt 1939 or earlierDetached single-family2-unit buildings3- or 4-unit buildingsMedian home value
Glen Ridge1939 or earlier81%85%2%1%$836,600
Maplewood1939 or earlier55%61%15%3%$720,700
Montclair1939 or earlier59%50%10%9%$906,400
South Orange194644%59%5%1%$866,600
Bloomfield195038%41%13%15%$470,800
Belleville195132%42%20%8%$421,000
Nutley195331%54%12%8%$516,300
Essex Fells195436%93%1%2%$1,083,000
Millburn (incl. Short Hills)195433%79%6%3%$1,371,500
Verona195433%62%6%4%$608,400
East Orange195632%20%14%13%$365,900
West Orange195625%53%11%6%$557,300
Orange195828%16%13%13%$365,500
Caldwell195930%28%11%8%$575,400
Cedar Grove19599%66%3%5%$634,000
Irvington196024%18%20%19%$335,600
West Caldwell196117%81%5%1%$659,100
Livingston19629%85%0%1%$821,100
North Caldwell196512%87%0%1%$904,500
Newark196624%13%18%22%$373,700
Fairfield19743%76%1%0%$688,500
Roseland197515%57%2%3%$665,700

Source: Census Reporter, ACS 2024 5-year, tables B25024, B25034, B25035 and B25077 for Essex County municipalities. Millburn's figures include Short Hills.

What stands out in the table:

  • In Glen Ridge, 81% of homes were built in 1939 or earlier. In Montclair it is 59%, and in Maplewood 55%.
  • In Newark, 13% of homes are detached single-family houses. 22% are in three- or four-unit buildings and 18% in two-unit buildings.
  • Irvington is similar: 18% detached, 20% two-unit and 19% three- or four-unit.
  • Essex Fells, North Caldwell, Livingston, Glen Ridge and West Caldwell are 81% to 93% detached single-family homes.
  • Median home values run from $335,600 in Irvington to $1,371,500 in Millburn.

4. What a Town's Housing Does to the Bid

The Census table does not price a roof. It tells you which questions to ask before you compare bids.

Older homes: Glen Ridge, Montclair, Maplewood, South Orange

  • Ask how many layers are on the roof now. Montclair's residential historic design guidelines say to re-roof over an existing roof only once with asphalt or composite roofing, to a maximum of two layers.
  • Ask whether the bid includes replacing damaged sheathing, and at what price per sheet. The Cost vs. Value job tears off to bare wood sheathing; its description lists no new sheathing.
  • Ask what the new roof will look like. Montclair's guidelines tell owners to use the materials originally on the building, or alternates with similar texture, scale, color and thickness, and to preserve the original roof form.
  • If the house is in a local historic district, check the town rules before you choose a different material (section 5). Our historic home roofing guide for Essex County covers older roofs in more depth.

Two- to four-unit buildings: Newark, Irvington, Orange, East Orange, Bloomfield, Belleville

  • Ask whether the roof is pitched, low-slope or both. A low-slope section needs a membrane system, priced in the flat roof replacement cost guide, not by the asphalt figure above.
  • Ask whether your building needs a permit. New Jersey's no-permit line names detached one- and two-family dwellings. Three- and four-family buildings and attached houses are not in that line.
  • Ask how the crew will protect tenants, entrances and parked cars during tear-off.

Newer housing: Livingston, Roseland, Fairfield, North Caldwell, West Caldwell

  • These towns have median years built from 1961 to 1975. Ask the roofer to count the layers already on the roof before quoting.
  • Large single-family houses mean more squares. Use the per-square table above with your own roof's measured area, not the house's floor area.

5. Permits and Historic Review

New Jersey's Uniform Construction Code applies in every Essex County town. It lists "the repair or replacement of existing roof covering on detached one- and two-family dwellings" as ordinary maintenance. The code says no permit for, inspections of, or notice to the enforcing agency of ordinary maintenance is required.

The same rule says ordinary maintenance does not include:

  • Any work affecting structural or fire safety.
  • Removing or cutting a structural beam or bearing support.
  • Work that increases a building's nonconformity with the regulations.

A three- or four-family building or an attached house is not named in the roof line. Call your town's construction office before work starts on one of those.

Historic districts: the Montclair example

Montclair has designated local historic districts. Inside them, its Historic Preservation Commission issues Certificates of Appropriateness. Montclair's rules for roofs:

  • No certificate is needed for "maintenance and repair of existing roofing materials involving no change in the design, scale or appearance of the structure."
  • A certificate is needed for a change in the exterior elevation or any improvement by addition, alteration or replacement.
  • Montclair's residential historic design guidelines say "A change of roofing material requires HPC review."
  • Montclair's Historic Preservation Commission page lists (973) 509-4955 for more information.

Other Essex County towns set their own historic rules. If your house is a landmark or in a district, ask the town before you order a different material.

Sources: N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.7 (PDF), Montclair, Certificate of Appropriateness, Montclair, Local Historic Districts, Montclair Residential Historic Design Guidelines (PDF), Montclair Historic Preservation Commission.

6. Replacing a Roof in Winter

GAF's instructions say its shingles carry a thermal sealant that bonds them together when exposed to sun and warm temperatures. The manufacturers' own instructions say what to do when that warmth is missing:

  • GAF's technical bulletin names hand-sealing as the method to assure sealing on very steep slopes, in high wind areas and when installing in cold weather.
  • GAF's Royal Sovereign instructions say shingles installed in fall or winter may not seal until the following spring, and that shingles applied during prolonged cold periods must be hand sealed.
  • Owens Corning's Duration instructions say that below 40 degrees F, every shingle on the perimeter of the roof must be hand-sealed with four 1-inch dabs of asphalt cement.
  • The same Owens Corning instructions call for a gap of no more than 1/16 inch at the end joints of field shingles, so the shingles do not buckle against one another in warmer weather.

If you replace a roof between November and March, ask the estimate to say how the crew will seal the shingles. If you have a leak now and plan to replace in spring, a repair is a separate, taxable job (section 7). R&E Roofing takes emergency calls on nights and weekends.

Sources: GAF technical bulletin TAB-R-114, hand-sealing shingles (PDF), GAF Royal Sovereign application instructions (PDF), Owens Corning Duration installation instructions.

7. Sales Tax: A New Roof Versus a Repair

New Jersey's sales tax rate is 6.625%. The Division of Taxation answers the roof question directly:

  • "The installation of a new roof is an exempt capital improvement and as such the charges are not subject to tax."
  • You give the contractor a completed Certificate of Exempt Capital Improvement, Form ST-8, to document it.
  • "Installation of replacement shingles is repairing real property and as such the charges are subject to tax."
  • The Division says the purchase of materials and supplies is subject to tax, whether the property owner or the contractor buys them.

Sources: New Jersey Division of Taxation, sales and use tax FAQ, Form ST-8 (PDF).

8. Roof Lifespan and Resale

InterNACHI publishes estimated life expectancies for roof materials and says they are guidelines only, not guarantees.

InterNACHI estimated life expectancy, years.
MaterialYears
Asphalt shingles, 3-tab20
Asphalt shingles, architectural30
Wood25
Modified bitumen20
Metal40 to 80
Slate60 to 150

The Cost vs. Value report also estimates how much of the job cost comes back in resale value:

Resale value added (share of job cost recouped), 2025.Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
AreaAsphalt roofMetal roof
New York, NY market$21,286 (57%)$27,008 (44.8%)
Middle Atlantic region$21,680 (58.3%)$27,270 (45.4%)
National average$21,501 (67.5%)$25,972 (50.1%)

Sources: InterNACHI, Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes, Cost vs. Value 2025, New York, NY.

9. What a Written Estimate Should List

Hold each bid against the Cost vs. Value job description and the Essex County points above. A written estimate should say:

  1. The roof area in squares, and how it was measured.
  2. How many layers come off, and that the tear-off goes to the sheathing.
  3. The price per sheet for any sheathing that has to be replaced.
  4. The shingle product line and weight.
  5. The underlayment, drip edge and eave protection used.
  6. New flashing at chimneys, skylights, walls and vents.
  7. The ridge vent or other ventilation.
  8. Any low-slope section and the membrane used on it.
  9. How shingles will be sealed if the job is done in cold weather.
  10. Whether a permit or historic review applies to your building.
  11. Disposal of the old roofing.

Questions Essex County Homeowners Ask

How much does a roof replacement cost in Essex County, NJ?

The 2025 Cost vs. Value report prices one defined job in every market it covers: tear off and replace a 30-square (3,000 square foot) asphalt shingle roof. It puts that job at $37,335 in its New York, NY market, $37,201 for the Middle Atlantic region and $31,871 nationally. We found no Essex County or Newark market in the report. Your roof's size, pitch, layers, sheathing and material move your own price from there.

What does a roof cost per square in Essex County?

A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof, as Owens Corning and GAF both define it. The Cost vs. Value New York market figure works out to about $1,245 a square ($37,335 divided by 30 squares). That is arithmetic on a published number, not a quote. GAF notes that a contractor adds a waste factor and may adjust the price for a roof's complexity and pitch.

Do I need a permit to replace my roof in Essex County?

Not for the roof covering on a detached one- or two-family house. New Jersey's construction code lists the repair or replacement of existing roof covering on detached one- and two-family dwellings as ordinary maintenance, which needs no permit, inspection or notice. Work affecting structural or fire safety is not ordinary maintenance. A three- or four-family building or an attached house is not named in that line, so ask your town's construction office first.

Does a Montclair home in a historic district need approval for a new roof?

It depends on what changes. Montclair says maintenance and repair of existing roofing materials with no change in the design, scale or appearance of the structure does not need a Certificate of Appropriateness. Its residential historic design guidelines say a change of roofing material requires Historic Preservation Commission review. The Commission's page lists (973) 509-4955 for more information.

Can a roof be replaced in winter in New Jersey?

Yes, with care about sealing. GAF names hand-sealing as the method to assure sealing when installing in cold weather, and its Royal Sovereign instructions say shingles installed in fall or winter may not seal until the following spring. Owens Corning's Duration instructions say that below 40 degrees F every shingle on the perimeter of the roof must be hand-sealed with four 1-inch dabs of asphalt cement.

Do I pay sales tax on a new roof in New Jersey?

Not on the contractor's charges, if you give the contractor a completed Form ST-8. The New Jersey Division of Taxation says the installation of a new roof is an exempt capital improvement. It says the installation of replacement shingles is a repair and those charges are taxable. New Jersey's sales tax rate is 6.625%.

Should a 20-year-old roof be replaced?

Not on age alone. InterNACHI's life expectancy chart lists 20 years for 3-tab asphalt shingles and 30 years for architectural asphalt shingles. A 20-year-old 3-tab roof is at the end of its listed life; a 20-year-old architectural roof is not. The roof's condition decides it: curling, cracked or missing shingles, leaks and worn flashing.

How much of a new roof comes back when I sell?

In the 2025 Cost vs. Value report's New York, NY market, an asphalt roof replacement costing $37,335 added an estimated $21,286 in resale value, or 57%. For the Middle Atlantic region the figure is 58.3%, and nationally 67.5%. These are estimates from the report, not appraisals of any one house.

Sources

All read November 18, 2026.

A Written Roof Estimate for Your Essex County Home

R&E Roofing's office is at 573 Valley St, Orange, NJ 07050. See roof replacement for what the job covers. Send your address, the roof's age and anything you have noticed. You get a written, itemized estimate you can hold against the tables on this page.

Office hours are Monday to Friday, 9 to 5, and we take emergency calls on nights and weekends.

Call (667) 204-1609

Request an Essex County roof estimate

Choose Roof Replacement under What do you need, and add what you know about the roof: its age, layers, skylights, chimneys or flat sections, and your town.

By sending this you agree to be contacted about your roof. R&E Roofing, Orange, NJ. Office hours Monday to Friday, 9 to 5.

Call (667) 204-1609Request an estimate